The poem takes place in the month of November and the poets sorrow is talking throughout the piece.
Written in a few weeks as a response to a proposed nuclear testing moratorium and other issues, it has been interpreted and misinterpreted, praised and excoriated. It recently generated hundreds of "reviews" on the Amazon.
Long on philosophical discussions about citizenship, government, and sociology, this is a book that can be read on several levels: It virtually defined the powered armor subgenre of military science fiction. It also generated an awful lot of mail, most of it negative. Lest anyone later accuse me of having a hidden agenda, let me make my agenda public at the outset: Starship Troopers might just be my favorite book of all time.
To see my letter to the editor of Science Fiction Chronicleand any further details of the resulting corespondence between Mr. I have no problems with people disliking or even condemning the book for its contents; it is a controversial work, and while I personally think that "polemic" is a little extreme, I can see why someone might describe it that way.
What I do not accept, though, is condemning the book on the basis of willful ignorance or poor reading comprehension. More about this below. To further complicate matters, Heinlein occasionally makes contradictory statements about the society portrayed in the book.
While I disagree with Heinlein on a number of issues including the one that prompted him to write the book in the first placeI do agree wholeheartedly with his take on citizenship; that with rights come responsibilities, and that many if not all of the major problems facing the western democracies today -- especially the United States -- are the result of people having forgotten that simple fact.
After some aptitude testing and preliminary screening, young Johnny finds himself at a boot camp so rigorous only ten percent of the recruits finish basic training. He survives, is assigned to a unit, takes part in a few operations, almost gets killed, goes career, attends Officer Candidate School, is commissioned, and eventually commands his own unit.
Interspersed through this are flashbacks to his high school History and Moral Philosophy course. These flashbacks are not filler; indeed, in many ways they are the core of the book.
Those residents who have not exercised their right to perform this Federal Service retain the other rights generally associated with a modern democracy free speech, assembly, etc.
This structure arose ad hoc after the collapse of the 20th century western democracies, brought on by both social failures at home and defeat by the Chinese Hegemony overseas.
Some of the participants have made cogent points based on a thorough understanding of both the book in specific and the military in general. Other people, though, have made the following comments.
Starship Troopers was written in response to real-world situations, and Heinlein certainly argued in defense of the book that the current method of awarding the franchise -- accidental birth in the country in question, followed by surviving long enough to reach the age of majority -- is, by itself, a somewhat haphazard way of guaranteeing that the enfranchised are prepared to exercise their privilege in a responsible manner.
On the other hand, he has also specifically stated in private correspondence submitted to the Quotable Heinlein page that his "fictional characters speak for themselves, not [Heinlein]. I also think there are prices too high to pay to save the United States.
Conscription is one of them. We have had the draft for twenty years now; I think this is shameful. Let the damned thing go down the drain! This is just my belief, however -- if someone has a solid quote from Heinlein on the subject, I would love to hear about it.
None of these assumptions are supported by the evidence in the book. The first assumption -- that the military is in charge of the government -- was addressed by Heinlein himself in Expanded Universe: No military or civil servant can vote or hold office until after he is discharged and is again a civilian.
The military tend to be despised by most civilians and this is made explicit. I have heard the dictatorship claim made on several occasions, yet seems to be totally without any support whatsoever.
It seems to be based on the assumption that any limitation on the franchise is undemocratic, which is clearly without historical context. Every democracy, past or present, has put limits on the franchise. Ancient Athens, the Roman Republic, and Revolutionary America to name but a few limited the franchise to male free landowners of majority age -- distinctly less than half the population.Nov 13, · For me, “My November Guest” captures all this – both the physical landscape and one’s emotional response to it – to a t.
It’s just one reason that each year as the seasons start to turn from fall to winter, Robert Frost lines suddenly start popping in my head. The Poets Robert Frost () Bookmark this page Manage My Reading List.
About the Poet. Robert Lee Frost, New England's cherished poet, has been called America's purest classical lyricist and one of the outstanding poets of the twentieth century. Although he is forever linked to the stone-pocked hills and woods of New England, he was born.
Oct 22, · In “A Girl’s Garden” by Robert Frost, the theme expressed is the unique pleasure of a rural childhood, as well as the girl’s youthful exuberance about the garden she grew. The speaker is a neighbor of the girl, who is now an adult woman living in town.
Posted on November 12, by masonsmommy Reply Although the book and film of Ernst Hemingway’s “The Snows of Kilimanjaro” are very different, there are some similarities.
Robert Heinlein's Starship Troopers Introduction and background Since its debut in , Robert Heinlein's novel Starship Troopers has been one of the most popular -- and controversial -- works of science fiction ever published.
Written in a few weeks as a response to a proposed nuclear testing moratorium and other issues, it has been interpreted and misinterpreted, praised and excoriated.
The world outside my window essays molly whuppie analysis essay important moment in my life essay, November 2, Cardiff City House of Sport & Cardiff International Sports Campus can confirm track & field facilities will re-open within next few days.